In stata add scalex2 or scaledev in the glm function. Modeling underdispersed count data with generalized poisson regression. Recent developments in panel models for count data pravin k. This variable should be incorporated into a poisson model with the use of the exp option. Cameron and trivedi microeconometrics uisng stata 2010, s. You can type search fitstat to download this program see how can i used the search. Apr 23, 2017 i am trying to decide the regression model between poisson and negative binomial. Besides, we show abundant distributional properties such as overdispersion and underdispersion, logconcavity, logconvexity infinite divisibility, pseudo compound poisson. In some cases the remedy is such that when applied, the model is no longer overdispersed. We also show how to do various tests for overdispersion and for discriminating between models. A significant p poisson model with the use of the exp option. Therefore, poisson distribution does not work in the case of overdispersion or underdispersion. Glm in r negative binomial regression v poisson regression. Pseudo rsquared measures for poisson regression models with.
Extended poisson inar1 processes with equidispersion. Fit the model to the data, dont fit the data to the model. We investigate the performance of rsquared measures for poisson regression models under overand underdispersion when ignoring the fact of over underdispersion and compare these. This command allows for the estimation of a poisson regression model with two high dimensional fixed effects. As david points out the quasi poisson model runs a poisson model but adds a parameter to. In many distributions, variance has a specific function form, which is called nominal variance. The common occurrence of extra poisson and extrabinomial variation has been noted by several authors. While the focus of this article is on modeling data with underdispersion, the new command for fitting generalized poisson regression models is also suitable as an alternative to negative. Count outcomes poisson regression chapter 6 exponential family. The poisson regression model is frequently used to analyze count data. Deviance goodness of fit test for poisson regression the. Underdispersion is also theoretically possible, but rare in practice. Stata version probability distribution calculators mac\teaching\ stata \ stata version \ stata v probability distribution calculators. Models and estimation a short course for sinape 1998 john hinde msor department, laver building, university of exeter, north park road, exeter, ex4 4qe, uk.
Abstractthe poisson regression model is often used as a first model for count data with covariates. For example, poisson regression analysis is commonly used to model count data. Colin cameron and per johansson, count data regression using series expansion. Article information, pdf download for modeling underdispersed. Zeroinflated regression model zeroinflated models attempt to account for excess. There are many possible causes and alternative approaches for modeling. While the focus of this article is on modeling data with underdispersion, the new command for fitting generalized poisson regression models is also suitable as an alternative to negative binomial regression for overdispersed data. As an example, suppose we examine the impact of the median income in thousands of families in a neighborhood on the number of burglaries per month. Dem etrio abstract we propose a new class of discrete generalized linear models based on. Quasipoisson model assumes variance is a linear function of mean. The nb regression assumes overdispersion and stata forces the variance of the neglected heterogeneity alpha to be positive. Recall from statistical theory that in a poisson distribution the mean and variance are the same. The zeroinflated poisson zip distribution 2 and the negative binomial distribution 3,4 have been proposed to catch this overdispersion in practical data.
Modeling overdispersed or underdispersed count data with. Any suggestions would be highly appreciated, regards, sonia menon. I would like to ask how could i perform a test for overdispersion with stata. Identifying the source of overdispersion can help in finding a remedy for it.
Stata module to estimate fixedeffects poisson quasiml. Students are taught that count data often follows a poisson distribution, so some type of poisson analysis might be appropriate. However, in practice, many counting data show some overdispersion, the variance is greater than the i. Introduction the problem of overdispersion introduction in this lecture we discuss the problem of overdispersion in logistic and poisson regression, and how to include it in the. When we have underdispersion, the algorithm tries to take alpha to zero, but that is impossible because the way stata parameterizes it.
Many software packages provide this test either in the output when fitting a poisson regression model or can perform it after fitting such a model e. Request pdf modeling underdispersed count data with generalized poisson regression we present motivation and new stata commands for modeling. The data is in stata format, and you can download it from the econ 508 web site. Underdispersion does not have an obvious explanation. While the focus of this article is on modeling data with underdispersion, the new. As a natural extension of the poisson distribution, the generalized poisson gp distribution, introduced in 6 as an proximation of a generalized negative binomial distribution and studied extensively by consul 3 and consul and moye 5, is more flexible and allows for overdispersion or underdispersion. The large value for chisquare in the gof is another indicator that the poisson distribution is not a good choice. Underdispersion exists when data exhibit less variation than you would expect based on a binomial distribution for defectives or a poisson distribution for defects. If overdispersion is a feature, an alternative model with additional free parameters may provide a better fit.
However, if case 2 occurs, counts including zeros are generated according to a poisson model. In this paper, we establish several connections of the poisson weight function to overdispersion and underdispersion. The tests are designed to be powerful against arbitrary alternative mixture models where only the first two moments of the mixed distribution are. Weighted poisson distributions for overdispersion and.
In these families there are distributions with index of dispersion greater than, equal to or smaller than one. For count data, the reference models are typically based on the binomial or poisson distributions. Testing for overdispersion in poisson and binomial regression. Adaptations for handling overdispersion, underdispersion, autocorrelation, or inhomogeneity were proposed in the literature and presented here. However, the model requires equidispersion, which might not be valid for the data set under consideration. Negative binomial regression is for modeling count variables, usually for. Handling overdispersion with negative binomial and generalized poisson regression models to incorporate covariates and to ensure nonnegativity, the mean or the fitted value is assumed to be multiplicative, i. Three parameter count models can also be used for underdispersed data. You can type search fitstat to download this program see how can i use the. Modeling overdispersed or underdispersed count data with generalized poisson integervalued garch models. The key criterion for using a poisson model is after accounting for the effect of predictors, the mean must equal the variance.
Modeling underdispersed count data with generalized. You can install it by typing in stata ssc install simsum. As often proposed, i used the zero truncated poisson model for analyzing my data, but the problem is that there is significant underdispersion given. While the focus of this article is on modeling data with underdispersion, the new command for fitting generalized poisson.
We present motivation and new stata commands for modeling count data. Can quasi poisson glm be used for underdispersed count data. The outcome variable in a poisson regression cannot have negative numbers, and the exposure cannot have 0s. We use data from long 1990 on the number of publications produced by ph. The zeroinflated poisson regression model suppose that for each observation, there are two possible cases. Poisson glm can handle crash data when the modeling output shows signs of underdispersion. In this post well look at the deviance goodness of fit test for poisson regression with individual count data. A common solution is to assume that the variance is proportional to the. Can quasipoisson glm be used for underdispersed count data.
Tammy harris institute for families in society department of epidemiology and. In stata, a poisson model can be estimated via glm command with the log link and the poisson family. I am running a poisson regression with an exposure variable. Zeroinflated regression model zeroinflated models attempt to account for excess zeros. May 03, 2017 a brief note on overdispersion assumptions poisson distribution assume variance is equal to the mean. We will start by fitting a poisson regression model with only one predictor, width w via glm in crab. Negative binomial regression stata data analysis examples. Dear statalisters, i have to choose between an xtpoisson model and an xtnbreg model. We focus on the comtype negative binomial distribution with three parameters, which belongs to comtype a, b, 0 class distributions and family of equilibrium distributions of arbitrary birthdeath process. Detecting and testing overdispersion in poisson regression. Various tests for extra poisson and extrabinomial variation are obtained as special cases.
When i conducted a poisson glm, i found that the scale parameter was about 0. More examples are surfacing, however, that display underdispersion, warranting the need to highlight this phenomenon and bring more attention to those models that can better describe such data structures. Hello stata users, i am fitting a poisson longitudinal multilevel linear model using the mepoisson command and have been unsuccessful in finding the commands for 1 performing a goodness of fit test 2 correcting for overdispersion. It appears to be a question as to why adding a particular predictor can change the model from being underdispersed a 1. So far, what i know is that with the presence of overdispersion negative binomial is more appropriate than poisson.
Pseudo rsquared measures for poisson regression models have recently been proposed and bias adjustments recommended in the presence of small samples andor a large number of covariates. Specifically, we establish that the logconvexity logconcavity of the mean. Underdispersion can occur when adjacent subgroups are correlated with each other, also known as autocorrelation. Dean in this article a method for obtaining tests for overdispersion with respect to a natural exponential family is derived. You can type search fitstat to download this program see how can i used the search command. Stata module to estimate fixedeffects poisson quasiml regression. Thus, overdisp can be implementd without the necessity of previously estimating poisson or binomial negative models. I take the digest, and try to scan through the contents when possible.
Testing for overdispersion in poisson and binomial. The poisson model, a close relative of the survival model, is the basis for all count data models. Below is the part of r code that corresponds to the sas code on the previous page for fitting a poisson regression model with only one predictor, carapace width w. But, the problem is that the over or underdispersion is depending on what type of dependent variable i want to use. A copy of the powerpoint referenced in the video can be downloaded here. Pseudo rsquared measures for poisson regression models. Davis summary count data regression is as simple as estimation in the linear regression model, if there are no. Modeling underdispersed count data with generalized poisson. Poisson regression stata data analysis examples idre stats. Generalized linear models glms for categorical responses, including but not limited to logit, probit, poisson, and negative binomial models, can be fit in the genmod, glimmix, logistic, countreg, gampl, and other sas procedures. Significance tables for the exact variance test for the. Tables of critical values for overdispersion already exist e.
Hi fabio, it wouldnt be a mistake to say you ran a quasipoisson model, but youre right, it is a mistake to say you ran a model with a quasipoisson distribution. As david points out the quasi poisson model runs a poisson model but adds a parameter to account for the overdispersion. Bloomington prepared for 2010 mexican stata users group meeting, based on a. Count data often follow a poisson distribution, so some type of poisson analysis might be appropriate. While the focus of this article is on modeling data with underdispersion, the new command for. Mccullagh and nelder 1989 say that overdispersion is the rule rather than the exception. The best and standard ways to handle underdispersed poisson data is by using a generalized poisson, or perhaps a hurdle model. Stata module to estimate a poisson regression with. Overdispersion is the condition by which data appear more dispersed than is expected under a reference model. In practice, however, data are often over or sometimes even underdispersed as compared to the standard poisson model. The purpose of this session is to show you how to use stata s procedures for count models including poisson, negative binomial zero inflated poisson, and zero inflated negative binomial regression. But here we are referring to nb overdispersion, not poisson overdispersion. Poisson regression is used to model count variables.
The value of generalized poisson regression is its ability to model poisson underdispersion, which is not possible for the. The exposure variable in poisson regression models the. According to the authors, the data set is based on the. This property makes them suitable to fit discrete data in overdispersion or underdispersion situations. Estimation is implemented by an iterative process using the algorithm of iteratively reweighted least squares irls that avoids creating the dummy variables for the fixed effects. Home lecture notes stata logs r logs datasets problem sets. Finally, they also show that the model proposed in this study provides better statistical performance than the gamma probability and the traditional poisson models, at least for this data set. The data are strongly skewed to the right, clearly ols regression would be inappropriate. Models for count data with overdispersion germ an rodr guez november 6, 20 abstract this addendum to the wws 509 notes covers extra poisson variation and the negative binomial model, with brief appearances by zeroin ated and hurdle models. Probabilitya stata commands for modeling count data. Citeseerx document details isaac councill, lee giles, pradeep teregowda. This module should be installed from within stata by typing ssc install xtpqml. Real count data time series often show the phenomenon of the underdispersion and overdispersion. Count data is often considered to have a poisson distribution, but such data can exhibit more variability than expected under that distribution.
581 69 868 1441 1146 501 261 225 1339 432 352 812 841 1303 21 93 763 981 1418 653 638 998 220 1026 293 1137 1116 391 900 718 1490 524 884 1382 1073 376 1099 30 113 186 5 1105 604 1317 383 672 1092 481 220